Head to head
Private Internet Access vs Surfshark
Cheapest long-term, unlimited devices, open source; it's American. Against: cheapest way to cover every device in the house.
Best plan
$2.03/mo · 3 years + 3 months·
$2.49/mo · 2 years + 3 months
Up front
$79.00
$67.23·
Renews at
$26.33/yr·
$79.00/yr
Monthly
$11.95·
$16.45
Devices
Unlimited
Unlimited
Countries
104·
100
No-logs audit
Deloitte 2024
Deloitte 2025·
Open source
yes·
no
Pay without a name
crypto
crypto
Based in
United States (5 Eyes)
Netherlands (9 Eyes)
Netflix
iPlayer
·
Torrenting
Blocked networks
·
Speed
Refund
30 days
30 days
Free tier
no
no
A dot marks the better number on that row. Numbers carry their dates on each provider’s page.
Which one, for which job
- Best VPN for streaming
Surfshark
- Best VPN for privacy
Private Internet Access
- Best VPN for travel
Surfshark
- Best VPN for torrenting
Private Internet Access (close)
- Best cheap VPN
Surfshark (close)
- Best monthly VPN
Private Internet Access (close)
- Best VPN for multiple devices
Surfshark (close)
- Best VPN for China and blocked networks
Surfshark
- Best VPN for gaming
Private Internet Access (close)
- Best free VPN
neither · Private Internet Access, Surfshark filtered out
- Best VPN for the UK
Surfshark (close)
Private Internet Access
- +Lowest cost over three years
- +Unlimited devices
- +Open-source apps; no-logs tested in court
- –US company, 5 Eyes
- –Weak where VPNs are blocked
Visit Private Internet AccessNot an affiliate link. Opens the provider's site.
Surfshark
- +Unlimited simultaneous devices
- +Lowest intro price of the audited providers
- +P2P on all servers
- –Netherlands is a 9 Eyes country
- –Not open source
Visit SurfsharkNot an affiliate link. Opens the provider's site.